Skip to main content

ID fraud vs identity theft vs credit card theft: what is the difference?

(Image credit: Pixabay)

You've heard of ID fraud. You're pretty sure you know what identity theft is. And you know someone who has had their credit card stolen. But aren't they all the same thing - three sides of the same problem?

In a way, yes, they are. But the differences between identity theft, credit card theft, and ID fraud can help you not only appreciate what each is but spot the risks to you and act accordingly.

What is identity theft?

This is perhaps the simplest definition. Identity theft is essentially self-descriptive - it means a person's details are stolen. That person might be an adult, a child, or they might even be deceased. Identity theft relies on enough data being stolen that someone can convincingly pose as the victim.

These days, identity theft is mostly thought of as an online crime, but there are plenty of offline methods to steal an identity. For example, an identity thief might check your rubbish for discarded statements and other financial information. They might steal your post to learn information about you. Thieves can also steal what they need from your wallet or purse. Driving license, credit card, membership card for a public body - these are all enough to learn enough about you to take out credit in your name.

Stealing someone's identity in person requires more effort than sitting behind a computer. Increasingly, identity theft is becoming an online crime, with phishing emails and instant messages leading people to innocently hand over their login data for banks and credit card websites, conned into thinking the websites are legitimate. Phishing is a key feature of online identity theft, although it can just as easily be executed over the phone.

An identity thief needs your name, date of birth, and address to get started. This information can be enhanced with social media activity. For example, a scammer might check your Facebook account for talking points about what you've been doing to seem utterly convincing as they take out a loan in your name.

Suspect your identity has been stolen? Contact your bank, credit card company, and if necessary, the police.

What is ID fraud?

Once identity theft is successful, ID fraud can take place. This is the practice whereby an identity theft fools a bank or credit card company into handing over money and/or information about the victim.

It is essentially fraud achieved with someone else's identity.

ID fraudsters can use your details to open a new bank account, apply for new credit cards and loans, acquire state benefits, order goods, take out a mobile phone contract, take over your existing bank, credit, and property accounts, and even grab legitimate duplicates of your official documents. This includes things like passports and driving licenses.

(Image credit: Shutterstock)

What is credit card theft?

If a criminal doesn't have the time of resources to steal your entire identity, he or she might prefer to simply steal your credit card. Debit cards are also included in this type of theft.

There are three main types of card theft: physical theft, cloning, and skimming. If your wallet is stolen, then physical theft has occurred. A card can be cloned following physical theft, or the data simply skimmed from it and stored in a database. Here, it awaits downloading to a new fake card which can then be used like a genuine credit card.

Skimming is a key risk of paying by credit card. Skimmer technology is a compact method of copying the data stored on your credit card. The data can then be used to buy goods or services that are charged to your account. Not only is there potential for restaurant and café employees to carry skimmers, ATMs and gas station "pay at the pump" systems are prone to interference. Usually, this means the installation of a skimmer.

Credit card theft naturally leads to credit card fraud. Here, goods might be obtained using the card and delivered to a remote location, such as an industrial estate unit. Alternatively, money might be transferred (by way of a fake "payment") to an account managed by the criminal.

The differences between ID fraud, identity theft, and credit card theft

Now you know understand what ID fraud is, along with identity theft and credit card theft. The differences should be quite clear, but if not, here's a recap:

  • ID fraud is fraudulent activity (taking out loans, extending credit, even acting in an official capacity) using someone else's stolen identity. 
  • Identity theft is the act of stealing an identity. It might be done offline or online. An identity can also be bought or sold online - some are stolen to order.
  • Credit card theft encompasses credit cards and debit cards. It refers to stealing (or duplicating) a card to use it for personal gain or transferring the balance to another account with a fake payment.

All these things are bad, but you can reduce your exposure to them:

  • Dispose of old bank statements and correspondence
  • Keep important documents safely locked away
  • Reduce social media activity and friends
  • Set a different password for every account, using a password manager
  • Enable two-factor authentication where available
  • Set a secure PIN or fingerprint authentication on your phone
  • Subscribe to SMS balance alerts with your bank and credit card provider
  • Sign up for monthly credit reports to check for credit applications in your name

digital lock

(Image credit: Pixabay)

ID fraud, identity theft, and credit card theft: Three sides of the same problem

The theft and subsequent fraud explained here are all linked. Not having a credit card won't stop identity fraud. Going off-grid won't prevent identity theft. These are aspects of modern life, enhanced by our reliance on instant connectivity into simultaneous benefits and threats.

Be aware of the differences between ID fraud, credit card theft, and identity theft. But remember that the issues are linked and behaving in a manner that keeps your data personal will help considerably.